I used to think that the New York Times was a liberal paper. When did they go over to the dark side? Maybe it all started with Maureen Dowd and the cannabis candy bar:
And the Times is known for lending its credibility to the opioid war. This article is the latest proof that the Times is running away from science. And so one has to wonder, how many white, middle-class employees at the Times have known and/or lost someone to drug addiction and the drug war? Or maybe they’re just choosing to be ignorant.
Since Jan. 4, St. Joseph’s Regional Medical Center’s emergency department, one of the country’s busiest, has been using opioids only as a last resort. For patients with common types of acute pain — migraines, kidney stones, sciatica, fractures — doctors first try alternative regimens that include nonnarcotic infusions and injections, ultrasound guided nerve blocks, laughing gas, even “energy healing” and a wandering harpist…
St. Joe’s is even cautiously trying therapies not typically taught in medical school. A nurse practitioner is studying acupuncture for pain. And another nurse, Lauren Khalifeh, the hospital’s holistic coordinator, does a treatment called “pranic healing.” …
On a recent weekday in the E.R., John Schiraldi, 25, a recovering heroin addict, was grateful that his merciless kidney stone pain was ebbing not because of intravenous morphine — a conventional E.R. protocol — but because of a regimen that included intravenous lidocaine, a non-opioid analgesic…
St. Joe’s pediatricians used a non-opioid protocol including a nasal spray of ketamine, a powerful drug which, in low doses, has analgesic and sedative properties…
And so although emergency physicians write not quite 5 percent of opioid prescriptions, E.R.s have been identified as a starting point on a patient’s path to opioid and even heroin addiction…
The E.R. staff is beginning to embrace the non-opioid options. “I’m thrilled,” said Allison Walker, a nurse. “I’d hate to be the first to give Percocet to a teenager who dislocated his knee at hockey practice. And then he comes back a year later, addicted to opioids? I don’t want that on my conscience.” …
“St. Joe’s is on the leading edge,” said Dr. Lewis S. Nelson, a professor of emergency medicine at New York University School of Medicine, who sat on a panel that recommended recent opioid guidelines for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention…
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention calculated that in 2014 there were 10,574 heroin overdose deaths and 14,838 for prescription opioids…
This article from 2013 shows the progression of how hospitals deal with painkillers:
Under the new city policy, most public hospital patients will no longer be able to get more than three days’ worth of narcotic painkillers like Vicodin and Percocet. Long-acting painkillers, including OxyContin, a familiar remedy for chronic backache and arthritis, as well as Fentanyl patches and methadone, will not be dispensed at all. And lost, stolen or destroyed prescriptions will not be refilled. It only applies to the city’s public hospitals. Which means it will largely be poor people who are forced to suffer pain that can easily be treated.”
I’m not going to say that alternative treatments for pain don’t work, just that they only work for a very small percentage of the patient population — like the stories depicted in the Times article. And their benefits don’t appear to last very long. A true investigative reporter would follow up with these patients, see how they’re doing in a year or two. Of course, a real reporter would have shown all sides to this story.
I find it odd that I have a better understanding of addiction than these “professionals” who work in a hospital. Treating acute pain with a painkiller, like a teenager with a dislocated knee, rarely puts the patient on a path to addiction. However, ignoring acute pain can most definitely cause a chronic pain condition for that patient in the future. Unfortunately for patients, after your pain goes from acute to chronic, you no longer deserve treatment. And even if your pain is acute, you still may be refused treatment.
Cindy, NJ, June 10, 2016
Beyond frustrated that addiction is now treated as a disease but chronic pain disorders treated like a lifestyle decision.
Lilikoi, Hawaii, June 10, 2016
As a practicing Emergency physician, I would love to have access to more non-narcotic therapies for my patients. Are opiates the first line of therapy for severe acute pain? Yes, much of the time they are, though there are some conditions such as migraines and kidney stones that will often respond better to non-opiate meds. Unfortunately, only a fraction of the patients I see with pain have acute conditions like broken bones or freshly ruptured spinal discs. A majority of the patients requesting pain killers in the ER have chronic pain syndromes like fibromyalgia, cyclic vomiting syndrome, chronic migraine, and chronic low back pain. They’re in the ER because they’ve through the opiates prescribed them in other settings, and need a fix for more. They will swear loudly, like many commenters here, that only opiates will do anything for their pain. This is partly because they are addicted to a tremendously addictive class of medications that in long term use cause heightened sensation of pain – opioid induced hyperalgesia. But it’s also partly because they’ve never really been offered pain remedies other than opiates or over the counter pills like Tylenol and Ibuprofen.
It’s good to know how ER doctors feel about chronic pain patients, although I find it hard to believe that many pain patients seek help at the ER these days. This doctor appears to blame addiction on hyperalgesia, which I guess could happen. But it seems to me that doctors find it easy to place blame on a lot of things that don’t apply to most patients, mainly to switch the blame from doctors onto patients.
And if this doctor is talking about chronic pain patients, then believing that we’ve only been offered pills to treat pain is just a flat-out lie. More likely, he’s talking about those who suffer from drug addiction. And I’m sitting here wondering, what would be so bad about treating drug addiction with opioids? For ERs, I guess it’s about drug addicts coming back for more drugs, and the possibility of diversion. But if there wasn’t a drug war, what would be the problem with treating drug addiction? If drug addicts had easy and affordable access to their drug of choice, what harm would they do to the public?
Maggie Chin, NJ, June 10, 2016
“And so although emergency physicians write not quite 5 percent of opioid prescriptions, ERs have been identified as a starting point on a patient’s path to opioid and even heroin addiction”
As an EM physician, I write a fair amount of very limited (10 pills) opioid prescriptions for painful conditions such as renal colic or severe back pain. It doesn’t make sense to me to say that ED’s are a “starting point” if we prescribe small amounts. I have NEVER, in 11 years of practice, met an EM physician who would prescribe a month’s worth of an opioid as noted in the article. However, I look up patients in the state database before prescribing, and we often see patients who have been prescribed 120 pills or more by “pain management” physicians yet still come to the ED trying to get more.
A true drug-seeker will continue to complain of pain no matter what “alternative” you attempt (and I have tried nerve blocks on some of these patients), say they have allergies to all other pain medications, and dramatically complain of severe pain for all the ED to hear. Compound all this with patient satisfaction surveys and you have a no-win situation for docs who are already trying to take care of multiple very sick patients…
So, these drug-seekers (pain patients) aren’t considered to be “sick”? More of a nuisance than anything for this doctor, probably because doctors are refusing to treat them. It’s like, what are you doing here, in a hospital with sick people? Yes, I’m a doctor, I help sick people, but I can’t help you.
As a pain patient, it’s good to know what behaviors are considered red flags to doctors. Unfortunately, these red flags are also very real medical conditions, like an allergy to medications. I find it sad that this doctor believes that nerve blocks should actually work for most patients, when that’s just not true. And if the nerve block doesn’t work, it’s the patient’s fault? If the injection doesn’t work, the patient is a drug addict because she wants her pain to be treated?
Should doctors dismiss science because of the fear of addiction and the drug war? Too late, it’s already happened.